Jul 03, 2005 even a cursory comparison of fichtes first published version of the wissenschaftslehre of 17945 with kants critical works reveals a striking methodological difference. The later wissenschaftslehre and the reception of fichtes. Daniel breazeale these selections provide a brief but comprehensive introduction to fichte s philosophical system and his place in the history of german idealism. Though fichte is a convinced kantian and inherits the dilemmas of dualism, he finds a way to advance the claim of certainty by diminishing the role of the thinginitself and by deriving all knowledge from a. Fichte tries to answer these questions by introducing his second and third principles. Fichte is concerned with how consciousness determines the self, and with how consciousness is determined by the self. Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings, 179700 book.
Fichte also publishes popular political writings on freedom and in defence of the french revolution 1793, which secures his reputation as a radical. He shares his desire to uproot current conceptions completely and to accomplish a complete revolution in a way we think about these issues fichte notes his system is none other than the kantian system. Recently, philosophers and scholars have begun to appreciate fichte as an important philosopher in his own right due to his original insights into the nature of selfconsciousness or self. In the spring of 1794 fichte chose wissenschaftslehre, a word composed of the terms for science or scientific knowledge and theory or doctrine, to designate his own, radically revised version of the transcendental or critical philosophy inaugurated by immanuel kant. The transformation of kants transcendental idealism. Johann gottlieb fichte 17621814 johann gottlieb fichte is one of the major figures in german philosophy in the period between kant and hegel. Johann gottlieb fichte is a key figure in the landscape of postkantian idealism. Fichte foundations of natural right according to the principles of the wissenschaftslehre. These selections provide a brief but comprehensive introduction to fichtes philosophical system and his place in the history of german idealism. Considered by some to be his most important text, this series of lectures given by johann gottlieb fichte 17621814 at his home in berlin in 1804 is widely regarded as the most perspicuous presentation of his fundamental philosophy. Inspired by his reading of kant, johann gottlieb fichte 17621814 developed during the final decade of the eighteenth century a radically revised and rigorously systematic version of transcendental idealism, which he called wissenschaftslehre of doctrine of scientific knowledge. In this paper i pursue the question whether transcendental explanation in fichte s wissenschaftslehre should be regarded as ontologically. The later wissenschaftslehre and the reception of fichtes philosophy. Johann gottlieb fichte german philosopher britannica.
Fichte s 1804 lectures on the wissenschaftslehre, translated with an introduction and notes by walter e. Introduction page vii chronology xxix further reading xxxi translators note xxxiv foundations of natural right, according to the 1 principles of the wissenschaftslehre introduction 3 first main division. Transcendental and ontological grounds in fichte sebastian gardner abstract. The first system of freedom the philosophical work of johann gottlieb fichte 17621814 is political through and through. Chapter 4 considers fichte s conception of such a system, and stresses the importance of political, ethical and pedagogical themes to this conception. Through technical philosophical works and popular writings fichte exercised great influence over his contemporaries, especially during his years at the university of jena. It is hoped that through this course, students will come to know fichte s seminal science of knowledge, appreciate the origins of schellings own philosophizing independent of fichte, and understand hegels emergence from out of the shadows of his predecessors. In addition to some of fichtes most influential texts, such as the first and second introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and the basis of our belief in a divine governance of the world, breazeale has translated, for the first time into english, several other writings from the same period, including attempt at a new presentation of the. Part 2 of this thesis considers fichte s attempt to develop a theory of intersubjectivity within his system of transcendental philosophy or wissenschaftslehre. Introduction to fichtes science of knowledge wikisource, the free. In presenting this introduction to the readers of the journal of speculative philosophy, we believe we afford them the easiest means of gaining an insight into fichtes great work on the science of knowledge. In addition to some of fichte s most influential texts, such as the first and second introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and the basis of our belief in a divine governance of the world, breazeale has translated, for the first time into english, several other writings from the same period, including attempt at. Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings, d.
Fichte is attempting to identify the proposition i am i as the absolute ground of all knowledge. Indeed, i intend to define the meaning of hegelian logical dialectic, for the. Johann gottlieb fichte was a german philosopher who became a founding figure of the philosophical movement known as german idealism, which developed from the theoretical and ethical writings of immanuel kant. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here.
Johann gottlieb fichte stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. A well translated collection of writings pertaining to the wissenschaftslehre. Fichte s short book the vocation of man 1800 is both an introduction to and a defense of his philosophical system, and is one of the bestknown contributions to german idealism. Starting with lectures in 1796 wissenschaftslehre nova methodo and publications in 17978. Taking seriously the ontological division between a free and enslavedenslaving humanity repeatedly maintained by fichte, i argue that what is at stake in the fichtean practice of the wissenschaftslehre, as a critical and liberating practice, is a becomingother in the strong sense of the term. Fichte s 1804 wissenschaftslehre as a critique of knowledge and a program of philosophical foundation. The present introduction was written by fichte in 1797, three years after the first publication of his full system.
According to fichte, the wissenschaftslehre must provide an account of the. Fichtes methodology in the wissenschaftslehre 179495. The present introduction was written by fichte in 1797, three years. Johann gottlieb fichte entered the field of german philosophy in the wake of immanuel kant 17241804 and just prior to g. Feb 02, 20 introduction to fichtes science of knowledge. In addition to some of fichte s most influential texts, such as the first and second introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and the basis of our belief in a divine governance of the world, breazeale has translated, for the first time into english. The second and more important text, foundation of the entire wissenschaftslehre 1 hereafter, foundation, was also addressed to fichtes students and written as a supplement to his lectures on the wissenschaftslehre in 179495. Seidel presents the english and german text of part 1 of the wissenscbaftsiebre, followed by a commentary on the text.
Such formulae are required to produce some of the main concepts of fichtes thought, and allow us to draw both systematic and historicalconceptual conclusions about it. Fichtes later years in berlin, his lectures on the theory of ethics sittenlehre. Pdf fichte is the first great postkantian idealist and his debt to spinozism has been acknowledged by virtually all of his commentators. Fichte1s modification of kants transcendental idealism in the wissenschaftslehre of 179 4 and introductions of 1797 charles griswold in this essay i study fichte s modification of kants transcendental idealism. By this point fichte has married hohanna rahm, daughter of a customs o. Johann gottlieb fichte, wissenschaftslehre nova methodo. According to the principles of the wissenschaftslehre. Pdf johann gottlieb fichte religionslehre yolanda estes. Helpful in introducing the reader to fichtes system.
Early philosophical writings and introductions to the wissenschaftslehre. While conceding that his own version departed in many respects from the letter of the kantian exposition, fichte insisted that his. He is the editor and translator of several volumes of fichtes writings, including fichte. Create a book download as pdf download as epub download. In addition to some of fichtes most influential texts, such as the first and second introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and the basis of our belief in a divine governance of the world, breazeale has translated, for the first time into english. Its purpose was to communicate the aims and method of his new philosophy to prospective students. Several papers explore the broader question of fichte s relationship and contribution to german idealism and german romanticism in general, while others offer comparative studies of the relationship between fichte s writings and those of leibniz, kant, schelling, hegel, friedrich schlegel, novalis, schleiermacher, and wilhelm. Fichte s wissenschaftslehre by kenneth angwe agede december 2009 dissertation supervised by tom rockmore this dissertation examines fichte s original philosophical system, or the wissenschaftslehre, against the background of kants transcendental idealism, and was conceived within the framework of restating kants critical philosophy. His lectures on the wissenschaftslehre nova methodo 17961799,6 which are preserved only in student transcripts, are also central documents for any informed understanding of fichtes early system. Fichte s wissenschaftslehre by kenneth angwe agede december 2009 dissertation supervised by tom rockmore this dissertation examines fichte s original philosophical system, or the wissenschaftslehre, against the background of kants transcendental idealism, and was conceived within the framework of restating kants critical. The first english translation of fichtes second set of 1804 lectures on the wissenschaftslehre.
Fichte, german idealism, and early romanticism brill. Johann gottlieb fichte, german philosopher and patriot, one of the great transcendental idealists. These are the members of the set of absolutely undeniable logical laws. The final version of this english translation is published as announcement in j. Perhaps the clearest exposition of ficthes wissenschaftslehre. When fichte enters the discussion, kant is already being torn apart by jacobi and the skeptics. In his system of transcendental idealism 1800, schelling sets out to combine the essential elements. His thinking, no matter how abstract, arid and seemingly removed from current affairs, reflected the. Fichte riprende quindi il primato della critica della ragion pratica che e quello di indicare come luomo puo andare oltre i contenuti del fenomeno dal punto di vista ontologico. It is certainly written in a remarkably clear and vigorous style, so as to be likely to arrest the attention even of those who have but little acquaintance with the rudiments of the science of philosophy. Initially considered one of kants most talented followers, fichte developed his own system of transcendental philosophy, the socalled wissenschaftslehre. Introduction with renewed attention to german idealism in general and to fichte in particular, this timely collection of new papers will be of interest to anyone concerned with transcendental philosophy, german idealism, modern german philosophy and transcendental arguments.
Fichtes preface and first introduction to wissenschaftslehre. This work is a model of what a philosophical text should be. Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings, 17971800. To some extent, of course, an intertwinement of theory and context is a universal feature of human thought. Perhaps the most characteristic, as well as most controversial. From 1794 up to the final year of his life in 1814, fichte attempted to formulate a unified philosophical programme that would combine, in a single system, the main branches of theoretical and practical philosophy. Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings 17971800 hackett classics 9780872202399. The work concludes with a summary of parts 2 and 3 of the wissenscbafislebre. Mey 19, 1762 januar 27, 1814, a german filosofer, acame a foondin figur o the filosofical muivement kent as german idealism, which developed frae the theoretical an ethical writins o immanuel kant. The early philosophy of fichte and schelling chapter 7 the. Fichtes wissenschaftslehre and hegels logic george di giovanni, mcgill university montreal abstract. The special relationship between logic and the wissenschaftslehre. Schelling, the philosophical rupture between fichte and schelling.
At the very beginning of part 2 of thewissenschaftslehre, fichte remarks that with the completion of part 1, and with it the establishment of the fundamental synthesis of self and nonself, the formal validity of his exercise in reflection is complete and the ground laid for the content gehalt of every other possible synthesis. Pdf it is not usual to think of fichte as a logician, nor indeed to think of him as. These selections provide a brief but comprehensive introduction to fichte s philosophical system and his place in the history of german idealism. There are amazing developments to critical philosophy in. New presentation of the wissenschaftslehre 17971798,5 and the system of ethics 1798. This dissertation argues the thesis that fichtes wissenschaftslehre is identical. Foundations of transcendental philosophy wissenschaftslehre nova methodo 179699 johann gottlieb fichte, daniel breazeale on. Fichte, johann gottlieb internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Paradox, incompleteness and labyrinth in fichte s wissenschaftslehre diogo ferrer 1.
Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings, 179700. Fichte s preface and first introduction to wissenschaftslehre my apologies for running behind procrastination, what in getting the reading notes up. On the form and development of the science of knowledge wl 1 although there are some similarities between the main divisions of fichte s successive expositions of the wl, especially after 1805, a. Fichte s old acquaintance from zurich, jens baggessen, writing to jacobi, expressed his astonishment at the way each line of this book refutes the wissenschaftslehre the standpoint of which baggesen, like so many oth. Fichtes wissenschaftslehre of 1794 book description. Based on lectures fichte had delivered as a professor of philosophy at the university of jena, it was later reworked in various versions. Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings, j. Introduction to fichtes science of knowledge wikisource. In 1797, subsequent to jacobis 1787 and schulzes 1792 objections against kantian criticism, fichte intends to. By doing this, fichte sets out to develop a coherent and definitive. Seidel presents the eng and german text of part 1 of the wissenscbaftsiebre, followed by a commentary on the text.
An elaborate and logically tight outline of the act of selfconsciousness. Fichte gives an overview of his plans to discuss his concept of the wissenschaftslehre. Fichte also publishes popular political writings on freedom and in defence of the french revolution 1793, which. The relationship between fichte s wissenschaftslehre and kants philosophy is as important as it is ambiguous. Written for a general audience during a period of intense controversy in the german philosophical community, j. Johann gottlieb fichte 17621814 german philosopher. Science of knowledge wissenschaftslehre with the first and second introductions. New perspectives on fichte s best known and most popular work. This is the meaning of his description, in his first introduction to the wissenschaftslehre, of philosophys. Introductions to the wissenschaftslehre and other writings. Three interpretations of the absolute i article pdf available in south african journal of philosophy 291 may 2010 with 211 reads. Educated at the pforta school 177480 and at the universities of jena 1780 and of leipzig 178184, he started work as a. Fichte and the relationship between selfpositing and rights.
91 1311 1151 1169 953 528 515 1312 1039 285 1060 1294 723 565 1169 346 975 754 190 136 864 1492 1151 1182 968 564 1431 638 489 85 1432 770 967 749 1413 79